Can a man be a woman

Added: Janalee Quezada - Date: 30.08.2021 22:13 - Views: 36955 - Clicks: 5985

The clear answer to this is no, he cannot. No matter how he presents himself, what he wears, what he believes about himself, or what changes he makes to his body through surgery or medical treatment, a male remains a male. A male cannot become a woman. Nor can a female become a man. The legislation which enables this is the Gender Recognition Act The criteria that individuals must meet and the process they need to go through are set out in the Act. What does a male have to do in order to legally become a woman? According to the provisions of the Act he must:. The report from the specialist must include details of the diagnosis of gender dysphoria.

Those individuals who meet the eligibility criteria and who successfully go through the required process have their details entered into the Gender Recognition Register and receive a Gender Recognition Certificate GRC. A GRC is a legal document which states that the individual to whom Can a man be a woman has been issued has satisfied the criteria for legal recognition in the acquired gender. A GRC enables that individual to have all official documentation, including documents which are used as proof of identity such as driving licence and passport, issued to reflect the acquired gender.

Even more ificantly, possession of a GRC enables that individual to obtain a new birth certificate which shows the acquired gender. If he has not had any surgery, or if no treatment has been prescribed for him, the specialist completing the medical report must explain why. Much less, is there any provision to revoke his Gender Recognition Certificate, which states that he is legally a woman, if he fails to complete the treatment that was described in the application form. What this means is that a male, complete with his fully-functioning and unaltered male body, can legally be a woman under UK law.

He can obtain a new birth certificate, passport, driving licence, etc which state that he is female, together with his new female name. His birth certificate will show this new name and will state that on the date of his birth a girl was born, not a boy. There will Can a man be a woman no indication on any of these documents that he was born male. The Act sets out provision to protect the privacy of those who obtain a GRC. What this means is that we are not allowed to know that this person who is legally a woman is of the male sex. Whilst the fact that he remains a male may be absolutely obvious, what this means is that we are not allowed to question his femaleness and are not allowed to take the precautions that we would normally take when presented with someone who is male.

The history of how the Gender Recognition Act came into being and the reasons behind it is interesting. Is this true? Or are there situations where he can still be treated as the male he is? The law is quite clear about this. There are situations where he is not treated as a woman. There are situations where he can be treated as a male.

The Equality Act Provide a legal framework to protect the rights of individuals and advance equality of opportunity for all.

It provides a discrimination law which protects individuals from unfair treatment and promotes a fair and more equal society. The Act specifies the following as protected characteristics: age; disability; gender reasment; marriage and civil partnership; pregnancy and maternity; race; religion or belief; sex; sexual orientation.

What this means is that a person A discriminates against another B if, because of a protected characteristic, A treats B less favourably than A treats or would treat others. Such discriminatory actions are illegal. What this means for a male with a GRC is that he cannot be treated differently on the basis that he has the protected characteristic of gender reasment. These are sports and single-sex spaces and services for women. To do so is not discriminatory.

For example, darts would arguably not be a gender-affected activity. Rubgy, as the evidence shows, most definitely is.

The Equality Act also provides for separate services for males and for females. At Schedule 3, Part 7 the Act states:. A person does not contravene [the Act] so far as relating to sex Can a man be a woman, by providing separate services for persons of each sex, if. This provision is elaborated upon at length. The following are of note as they establish the legal permissibility of single-sex services and single-sex spaces:.

A person does not contravene [the Act], so far as relating to sex discrimination, by providing a service only to persons of one sex, if. The condition is that:. A person does not contravene [the Act], so far as relating to gender reasment discrimination, only because of anything done in relation to a matter within [the following] sub-paragraph if the conduct in question is a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim.

The matters are:. This means that a male, notwithstanding possession of a Gender Recognition Certificate and birth certificate stating that he is female, and notwithstanding his protected characteristic of gender reasment, may be excluded from single-sex spaces and services for women and girls, where this is a proportionate means to achieving a legitimate aim. In Schedule 23, paragraph 3 of the Act communal accommodation is included in these single-sex services and spaces. The Gender Recognition Act In common with the Equality Actthe Gender Recognition Act at Section 19 makes provision in respect of gender-affected sports.

This means that it is legal to exclude a male with a GRC stating that he is legally a woman from single-sex sports for women in order to secure fair competition or the safety of the competitors. These are:. The provisions in respect of gender-specific offences are important and worth elaborating upon. At Section 20 the Act states:. The conditions are. What this provision means in that a male who has a GRC stating that he is legally a woman cannot avoid criminal liability if he commits a sexual offence.

It should be noted, however, that in a case like this the offence will be recorded in the female crime statistics as having been committed by a woman. You can about that at When males are recorded as women. In conclusion: a male with a GRC stating that he is legally a woman is not to be treated as a woman in all circumstances. This person may be treated differently and may be excluded from single-sex spaces and services for women, simply because he is male. To do so is legal and is not discriminatory. Policy is written as if these provisions in law simply do not exist.

This is an outrage and it leaves women in prison at risk. Can a male really become a woman? The Equality Act The purpose of the Equality Actas described by the Equality and Human Can a man be a woman Commission, is to: Provide a legal framework to protect the rights of individuals and advance equality of opportunity for all. At Schedule 3, Part 7 the Act states: A person does not contravene [the Act] so far as relating to sex discrimination, by providing separate services for persons of each sex, if a a t service for persons of both sexes would be less effective, and b the limited provision is a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim This provision is elaborated upon at length.

The following are of note as they establish the legal permissibility of single-sex services and single-sex spaces: A person does not contravene [the Act], so far as relating to sex discrimination, by providing a service only to persons of one sex, if The condition is that: a the service if provided for, or is likely to be used by, two or more persons at that same time, and b the circumstances are such that a person of Can a man be a woman sex might reasonably object to the presence of a person of the opposite sex The condition is that: a there is likely to be physical contact between a person A to whom the service is provided and another person Band b B might reasonably object if A were not of the same sex as B.

The matters are: a the provision of separate services for persons of each sex b The provision of separate services differently for persons of each sex c The provision of a service only to persons of one sex This means that a male, notwithstanding possession of a Gender Recognition Certificate and birth certificate stating that he is female, and notwithstanding his protected characteristic of gender reasment, may be excluded from single-sex spaces and services for women and girls, where this is Can a man be a woman proportionate means to achieving a legitimate aim.

The conditions are a that the offence may be committed only by a person of a particular gender, and b that the offence may be committed only on, or in relation to, a person of a particular gender, and the references to a particular gender include a gender identified by reference to the gender of the other person involved.

Can a man be a woman

email: [email protected] - phone:(180) 535-1326 x 2066

Transgender Women Are Women. Transgender Men Are Men.